Skip to main content

STUPID. It is a problem of Hsien Loong, not Tuck Yew.

2015 PAP Strategy 战略 7

It is really a problem of Lee Hsien Loong, not Lui Tuck Yew.   Loong creates more problems than Yew since he took over the prime ministership.  Transport is just one of the problems and the problem never gets solved by just removing Tuck Yew.

There are so many outstanding problems, for example, the economy, CPF, healthcare, population, education, housing, ….. As a commander-in-chief, you just cannot single out one minister and one ministry.  You need to look at the big picture. Voters will look at the total picture. Without transport, we can walk. Without money and medical care, people will die and die young. The stress of population crowds, schooling, and housing affect quality of life for many Singaporeans.

Seeing the bigger picture

So, Tuck Yew is just a small problem as compared the many big problems of Hsien Loong. Hsien Loong is really a ‘big big’ problem.  Tuck Yew is not capable in solving transport problem, so do Hsien Loong for the many national problems in Singapore.

It makes people more angry if Hsien loong continues to be the prime minister.

The PAP wants voters to focus on small picture and ignore the big picture. The PAP’s strategy is to remove Yew and keep Loong.

For the PAP, to get back votes and trust, the best strategy is to get rid of Lee Hsien Loong. Failing to see the big picture will cause the PAP dearly.  The PAP has other alternative ministers who can replace Lee Hsien Loong. Public confidence can be improved by replacing Loong.  Why is the PAP so afraid of change? It is a better change, a change of survival.

One or more GRC losses

Yew may cause the loss of one Group Representative Constituency. If Loong remains as prime minister, the impact is the whole country. All voters will look at him, judge him and rate his performance. Is Loong better than Yew in problem solving?

The PAP is quite stupid for failing to see the difference. Perhaps, they pretend all problems will go away with the departure of Yew - an unwanted candidate.  However, Yew can only cause a regional upset but Loong will cause a national upset, losing more GRCs.  

Sunzi Chapter 10 has the following advice for generals:

Education   Sun Tzu  The art of War    Ch. 9 to 13.png

Has the PAP putting the interest of the country first?

Projecting change but remaining conservative

The more we remember our past, the more conservative we are. The PAP wants to take advantage of ‘celebrating SG50, remembering LKY’. However, this confirms the conservative side of the PAP.

While having press conference introducing new candidates at a coffee shop is not a change, it is just a show.  Making every family in Singapore having a meal will make the PAP closer to the people.  

The publication of letters between Loong and Yew is not as transparent as the PAP wants to project. Do people really believe this is a show of ‘openness’ and not ‘wayang’?

Coffee shop talks and publishing exchange letters
are just public relationship. It does not show the sincerity and responsibility. According to Sunzi, this is just a ‘fame’.

Lesson from Najib

Loong pretends his reputation is still good and valuable to the PAP, just like Najib.  Najib beleived he could solve his problem by removing his deputy as he wanted a united cabinet.

Here in Singapore, Loong believes by removing Yew he can maintain a high productive cabinet, making voters believe all ministers are worth million dollars except Yew.

Najib is damaging the UNMO, so do Loong to the PAP.

Taking responsibility the Yew way

Yew made history to be first sitting minister to retire due to performance. Not long ago, the PAP said they would never do this to a minister.

He is resigning as a politician for not being able to solve a political problem.  At least he gains some respects as a general who shows some responsibilities. While Loong as commander-in-chief fires his general and pretends problems solved.

This is why Singaporeans see the PAP as a show party - LKY musical, 1965, …. The PAP wants to go back to the good old days and refuse to change. Keeping Loong as PM further confirms the 'no change' image.


  1. Astute analysis.
    On Sunzi's Chapter 10:
    1. PAP's cause is to maintain status quo, keeping Loong as their chief. Most if not all who can pose a leadership challenge have been removed, many by the chief's father and some say the mother. The name (or fame) or reputation so painstakingly built over the earlier decades has been quite thoroughly eroded. The symptoms are the anger and unhappiness of many ordinary citizens as well as the chief's low-standing in the eyes of many first-world countries and international agencies, i.e. no name/reputation.

    2. The chief would do well heeding the second advice but NO. There are too many concerns where no responsibility or accountability are given. The country's reserves, CPF, .... The MRT and transport problem is like you said one of the many problems. Ultimately the responsibility lies with the prime minister. So far he hasn't said much about taking responsibility for all the big problems the country is facing as a whole. (He did apologised before polling day 2011... ) And now all he said was he was doing his best, reminding people of what his father did as if that would absolve him of the responsibility.

    3. For the good of the country? Singaporeans deserve a better leader who will take care of as many Singaporeans as possible, take full responsibility for all the policies, consequences of those policies.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog






行动党和李显龙总理,就是看准了,看透了新加坡人的心理,表明这是司法程序,在法庭、在法律上,行动党政府都不会被打败。那些敢于挑战法律的人,在新加坡的短短50多年的建国历史中,下场都是以悲剧结束。最近的一个例子, 就是新加坡最年轻的政治犯余澎杉在美国的遭遇。同样一个人,不同的国情,命运也不一样。
今年的总统选举,基本上已经是没戏看了。大家大约都可以估算到结局。反而是三、四年后的大选,存在变数。 行动党也了解,要重获2015大选的佳绩,在没有造神运动的条件下,似乎是不可能。因此,要维持一个高得票率,就必须出一些怪招。把非选区议员人数增加到12位,就是给人民一个小甜头。如果真的上当,新加坡就清一色没有非行动党的市镇理事会了。

李显龙的幻象:新加坡人对他的 dishonorable 行为无动于衷。

李显龙当然有焦虑,正如他的妹妹和弟弟对他的指责:Dishonorable son。李显龙害怕人们对他的诚信起疑心,因此,在国会搞了一个自辩。既然国会没有提出相关资料证明他的诚信有问题,那李显龙就是清白了。
李显龙的确有焦虑,但是,他却认为新加坡人很乖,很听话: 给你们什么总统候选人,你们就会认命接受; 想提告什么人,就提告,法律面前人人平等,没有人有意见; 给什么议长人选,国会就认命接受; 地铁误点误事,任何解释,人民都会接受; 无现金就是无限金,跟不上是你的错; 糖尿病就少吃白饭,多吃糙米饭;。。。。
这是一种李显龙独特的焦虑幻象。他很焦虑,自己无法做得比老爸好,甚至连吴作栋都不如。他也焦虑在后工业时代,新加坡无法创造高薪职位给年轻人;新加坡无法照顾贫穷老弱,无法为他们提供医药服务; 接班人无法胜任挑战; 新加坡人在无限金时代,成了乡下佬; 地铁和教育服务提不上来; 。。。
陈川仁自愿减薪出任国会议长,不论是升职还是降职,已经充分说明,他在国会外,在行动党的职业保护伞外,无法找到一份比国会议长,还要高薪水的工作。 这点显示他不如海军出身的吕德耀。吕德耀即使找不到高薪职位,也毅然离开内阁和国会。 陈川仁,为李显龙成川成仁,却也凸显接班人的素质问题和骨气问题。他们离开了行动党的大树,如何面对现实生活?李显龙能…